Where’s the government involvement in local food?


One of the best things about the local foods movement has been how citizen-driven it is. That’s also been one of the most unfortunate things about it. A rash of articles out this week remind us that any substantial change in the nature of our food will need to be at the very least supported—and more probably, mandated—by government.

As proud as we can be of the strides that local food and farmers markets have made (and they are significant), they still represent only a drop in the bucket in the grand scheme of how most people eat. We spend a lot of time hailing organic farmers for choosing the hard row to hoe, and they certainly deserve the praise, but what’s lacking is a more concentrated criticism of government, and, more productively, a stronger lobby for change. Mary Hendrickson of the University of Missouri, quoted in Grist, puts it best: “Would I like to see [commodity grain farmers] get out of commodity crops? Certainly, but we better create a structure—fair and accessible markets for alternative crops and livestock, access to alternative seeds and inputs, transportation, processing etc.—that will better allow farmers to change.”

An article in the New Yorker about the issues surrounding establishing a carbon footprint says it bluntly: “Personal choices, no matter how virtuous, cannot do enough. It will also take laws and money.” Author Michael Specter cites the Clean Air Act of 1990, which was a great triumph—reducing emissions from 18 million to 9 million—and the also successful Clean Water Act of 1972, which obliged factories that polluted water to pay penalties. Because our current system is so heavily weighted in favor of agribusiness (with full, even excessive, government support), there isn’t currently enough incentive for most people to buy better food on a bigger scale. As Minnesota farmer Jack Hedin laments in a straight-forward New York Times op-ed, “the federal government works deliberately and forcefully to prevent the local food movement from expanding.” His own experience trying to lease a cornfield on which to grow fruit exposes how the rules buttressing commodity subsidies actively prevent local and regional fruit and vegetable production.

The small-farm-local-foods movement, a little David against a big Goliath, has done admirably well on its own, but it’ll take more than a slingshot to change the titanic momentum the food system has created as it industrialized over the past fifty years.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.plentymag.com/blog-mt1/mt-tb.cgi/4181


Post a comment

Issue 22



Sign up for Plenty's Weekly Newsletter